The main point of the debate seems to be the following: Over the past decades, several research groups of self-proclaimed creationist scientists have claimed discoveries of dinosaur bones that they have managed to date, using radiocarbon dating methods , at some age which is a lot below the ‘usual’ i. The age that these groups claim to find is usually on the order of thousands or tens of thousands of years old. The particular example you bring up is one of the most famous such cases. The claims are really quite spectacular, when taken at face value, and therefore should be examined thoroughly. In this answer, I will try to go through this story in great detail, hopefully exposing the reasons why this work is not taken seriously by scientists. The research by Miller et al. A research team from the CRSEF, or Creation Research, Science Education Foundation, led by Hugh Miller, has claimed to have dated dinosaur bones using radiocarbon methods, determining them to be no older than several dozens of thousands of years old. Let’s look at their research methodology in detail indicated by bullet points: As it turns out, Miller’s research group obtained their sample in quite a remarkable way.
New dinosaur dating technique paper released
According to evolutionary scientists, radiocarbon dating also known as carbon dating is totally ineffective in measuring time when dealing with millions of years. In his book, Genes, People, and Languages, renowned Stanford University geneticist Luigi Cavalli-Sforza, in a discussion on the theory of human evolution, commented on radiocarbon dating, stating: Staunch evolutionist Richard Dawkins also dealt with the limitations of radiocarbon dating a few years ago in his highly touted book, The Blind Watchmaker.
He was even more critical of this dating method than was Cavalli-Sforza, saying: Different kinds of radioactive decay-based geological stopwatches run at different rates.
May 09, · Dinosaur bones are too old. Carbon 14 has a half life of about years. There isn’t much in living material to begin with, and after 50, years so much has decayed that there’s too little for us to detect at : Resolved.
Scientists have known titanosaurs for a while, but this is a new species and even a new genus, which is a larger grouping, Pol said. Another titanosaur called Argentinosaurus was previously thought to be the largest. Media reports said several buildings were damaged and at least four people were killed and some were injured during the quake. Teams are trying to rescue people inside the buildings. Some bridges and roads are damaged and the main road to Hualien is closed.
More than earthquakes have hit off Taiwan’s east coast in the past three days. Around North Korean art performers in matching red coats and fur hats left for the South, its state media said on February 6, the latest in the flurry of cross-border exchanges in the run-up to the Pyeongchang Olympics. At least two were killed and dozens injured. Arbin is in the Eastern Ghouta region which has been under government siege since A ‘Supermoon’ commonly is described as a full moon at its closest distance to the earth with the moon appearing larger and brighter than usual.
Reuters Afghan police officers take position during a blast and gun fire in Jalalabad, Afghanistan. Thousands of Russian Orthodox Church followers will plunge into icy rivers and ponds across the country to mark Epiphany, cleansing themselves with water deemed holy for the day. Anees Ansari, Zainab’s father, accused the police of being slow to respond when his daughter went missing in the eastern Punjab province. Two people were killed and three others were wounded in clashes between angry Kasur residents and police after protesters enraged over her death attacked a police station in the city.
Triceratops Horn Dated to 33, Years.. Really
Here, RSR presents the scientific journals reporting, the kinds of biological material found so far, and the dinosaurs yielding up these exciting discoveries: Dinosaur and Dinosaur-Layer Creatures: As you view the exciting scientific discoveries below in this chronological catalog, please feel free to listen to Real Science Radio co-hosts Fred Williams and Bob Enyart observe their annual tradition of presenting dinosaur soft tissue and other amazing discoveries including short-lived left-handed amino acids , DNA , and Carbon 14 , all in bones and other specimens from dinosaur-layer Mesozoic and even deeper strata.
As for these photos though, North Carolina State University discovered this original biological tissue from a supposedly million-year-old Tyrannosaurus Rex thighbone, with transparent and pliable blood vessels containing red blood cells. See these and other T.
Aug 11, · – At Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Scientists dated dinosaur bones using the Carbon dating method. The age they came back with was only a few thousand years old. This date did not fit the preconceived notion that dinosaurs lived millions of years ago.
Opal Beleminite Photo Vassil Crystal World is careful to comply with legislation governing the trade in fossils in all jurisdictions. We have a large collection of stromatolites and microbialites for sale Photo Australian Museum Fossils Australia: Have you ever heard of Eric the Pliosaur? An amazingly intact marine Dinosaur completely replaced by precious gem opal, Eric resides at The Australian Museum. When Eric was alive, Australia was much closer to Antarctica.
Australia was joined to Antarctica, New Zealand and South America, forming the last remnant of the great southern landmass called Gondwana. About 80 million years ago New Zealand drifted away from the rest of Gondwana. The Australian part of Gondwana was located close to the South Pole. Southern Australia lay within the Antarctic Circle. Northern continents formed the great landmass Laurasia. These two supercontinents shared many plants and animals dating from an earlier time when they were joined as one enormous landmass.
Climate Australia had a cool, wet climate. For several weeks each year, parts of Australia may have had an icy polar winter including semi-darkness.
Earth’s Earliest Dinosaur Possibly Discovered
Triceratops Horn Dated to 33, Years Read the article on one page A Triceratops brow horn discovered in Dawson County, Montana, has been controversially dated to around 33, years, challenging the view that dinosaurs died out around 65 million years ago. The finding radically suggests that early humans may have once walked the earth with the fearsome reptiles thousands of years ago. The Museum, which has since been in cooperation with the Paleochronology Group, a team of consultants in geology, paleontology, chemistry, engineering, and education, sent a sample of the outer portion of the Triceratops brow horn to Head of the Paleochronology Group Hugh Miller, at his request, in order to carry out Carbon dating.
Mr Miller told Ancient Origins that it is always desirable to carbon date several fractions to minimize the possibility of errors which Miller requested and that essential concordance was achieved in the ‘s of years as with all bone fractions of ten other dinosaurs.
To determine the age of a dinosaur fossil, carbon dating can never be used. Carbon only works for fossils less than 75, years old.
Maybe it was just a few thousand years old — trapped by sediment in a catastrophic worldwide flood and fossilized. Since her initial discovery, Schweitzer, a molecular paleontologist at North Carolina State University, has found red blood cells, blood vessels, bone cells and even hemoglobin and collagen. A supposedly million-year-old duck-billed dinosaur bone has also yielded soft tissue.
The Christian Science Monitor reported this January that scientists found collagen, a protein basic to animal tissue, in an allegedly million-year-old fossil of a Lufengosaurus dinosaur in China. But Schweitzer, a conservative evangelical Christian who adheres to evolutionary theory, floated the theory in that iron may have preserved the soft tissue much like formaldehyde. If shown to be true, her theory would take wind out of the sails of the young earth Christians.
Schweitzer got her start in paleontology after studying molecular biology. She audited a course with famed paleontologist Jack Horner, the scientist who is trying to create dinosaurs in modern times from chicken DNA. Horner consulted for the movie Jurassic Park.
Dating Sedimentary Rock
In this case, the parent isotope will eventually decay and form a daughter isotope. It does this by losing nuclear particles over time. Radioisotopes are unstable but they eventually decay into a stable isotope.
Dinosaur bones with Carbon dates in the range of 22, to 39, years before present, combined with the discovery of soft tissue in dinosaur bones, indicate that something is indeed wrong with the conventional wisdom about dinosaurs.
The excavation, led by Xu, begun after construction crews erecting new apartment buildings accidentally uncovered dinosaur bones and other fossils, dating back million years. The excavation was begun after construction crews erecting new apartment buildings accidentally uncovered dinosaur bones and other fossils, dating back million years. Like many fossil excavation sites in China, this one was discovered by accident.
China’s rapid city building has churned up a motherlode of dinosaur fossils. While bulldozers have unearthed prehistoric sites in many countries, the scale and speed of China’s urbanization is unprecedented, according to the United Nations Development Program. Perhaps no one has seized the scientific opportunity more than Xu Xing, a diligent and unassuming standard-bearer for China’s new prominence in paleontology.
The energetic researcher has named more dinosaur species than any living paleontologist, racing between dig sites to collect specimens and further scientists’ understanding of how birds evolved from dinosaurs. Matthew Lamanna, a curator at the Carnegie Museum of Natural History in Pittsburgh, said Xu is “widely regarded as one of the foremost, if not the foremost, dinosaur paleontologist working in China today. Paul, Minnesota, wrote in an email. Two years ago, Xu’s colleague at the Chinese Academy of Sciences in Beijing, Jin Changzhu, was visiting family in Yanji when he heard talk of fossils uncovered at a construction site.
A preliminary inspection yielded what appeared to be a dinosaur shoulder bone. Less than an hour’s drive from the North Korean border, the midsize city has been erecting residential blocks quickly.
How is carbon dating used on dinosaurs if the half life of Carbon is years
Then, two weeks after publishing his findings, he was fired. Now California State University at Northridge has paid Armitage a six-figure sum to settle his wrongful termination suit based on religious discrimination. The case of Armitage is the latest to show the mounting hostility Christians face in academics and other public arenas.
The whole discussion of evolution ends if you show that the earth is young.
Mar 30, · Carbon dating is accurate only for about 50, years or m, uranium, potassium and possibly others are used to date dinosaur fossils because they have a half life greater than a million : Resolved.
Radioactivity causes disease and degeneration, which is not very good. The simple principle is the longer you have been dead, the less radioactivity you will have in your body. Ultimately it will be so little that it will be immeasurable. However, to use such a method you must assume the world that has always functioned the same as today. Carbon 14 is a short lived radioactive element with a half-life is only 5, years approximately.
So using current technology, you could at the most, use it for objects that only went back 70, or so years. The radioactive carbon combines with oxygen to produce carbon dioxide CO2 , which is absorbed by plants and get into food that is eaten by man and animals. To do that you have to have a way of knowing what the time was at measured known intervals back into the past. This means absorption of radioactive carbon by living things has not been the same throughout history, which means Carbon 14 decay dating methods cannot be relied on for accurate dates.
The monsters God made, and Dinosaurs: The rest of the tail These available from the Creation Research webshop.